Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

A well-lit living room with a marble countertop island, cabinet, golden chandelier and sofa set.

Just in Time for Valentine’s Day - What Does NJ Real Estate Have in Common With Online Dating?

Allison Ziefert Homes February 13, 2025

In honor of Valentine’s Day, I am updating and sharing an article that I wrote a few years back about what online dating and New Jersey real estate have in common. I can’t say I have had that much dating success since. I think I am a better realtor than an online dater:) Here is what I wrote:

I recently decided to test the waters with online dating. Being a naturally shy person, I did this with some trepidation.

Not knowing where to begin, I enlisted the assistance of a much more outgoing and experienced friend to help me. Which is best? Match, EHarmony, J Date, Bumble, Plenty of Fish, Tinder, OKCupid – so many choices. How do the sites work differently? Does the woman make the first move, or is she waiting to be contacted by men? My expert friend also helped me with my online profile- friendly but not too friendly, pictures with different looks and settings, honest but not honest to the point of seeming weird. It’s a balance!

I loaded up my profile, and it was off to the races. Once I started, it became fun–even relaxing. Every night I would get in bed and, instead of reading the New York Times on my iPad, I would check my inbox and start reading through profiles. I took my time reading through each one carefully. It was honestly fascinating to see how different guys presented themselves. Then I would swipe after viewing each one–left for “no” and right for “yes”.

It’s amazing how many profiles there are to look at. Eventually, I worked my way up to swiping faster and faster through profile after profile, having developed some basic criteria to quickly weed through tons of potential matches. It’s crazy to think of making a split-second judgment on a human being, but that’s what online dating is.

For example, if a guy attended the “school of hard knocks”, posed shirtless and was not at the beach, prominently displayed himself in front of any red vehicle or had excessive tattooing, stated an age and then in small print disclaimed that age (ie, my profile says I am 52 but I am 63) or did not take the time to write a description of themselves, I swiped left right away. Next!

Then it dawned on me. This is exactly what buyers do when they look at homes online. They may start carefully reading through online descriptions and looking at photos, but then they will progress to speed swiping. Think of buyers as potential dates. How do you make sure that your property gets a right swipe rather than a left swipe? How do you ensure that you are “matched” with as many potential “suitors” as possible so that you end up with the most qualified and best match?

Here are my top tips for success in the world of real estate matchmaking:

  • Preparation of the property – This is all important and can be time-consuming. You can’t jump straight into shooting photos for your online profile without doing the right prep, correct? You would need to select the right outfit, put on some makeup, and at least brush your hair! Unfortunately, many sellers don’t take the time to do the pre, or they don’t want to invest the money into properly preparing a house for viewing by potential suitors. An experienced realtor can tell you what you should do to prepare your home for both online photos and in-person viewings so that you don’t spend money on things that aren’t important and don’t overlook items that will be more critical to enticing the buyer pool. Just as you wouldn’t pose for your online photos after rolling out of bed, you need to take the time to get your property ready for the market.
  • Price – Most 35-year-olds don’t want to date a 70-year-old. The price category you select will be key in getting you in front of the right matches. Price is your biggest marketing tool, and buyers are smart about pricing. You can’t fool them. If a buyer is looking online for a 4BR/2BA house in Springfield between $750,000-$950,000 and yours looks the most attractive and interesting to the potential suitors, you will get a date. If yours looks like the 70-year-old guy in a crowd of 35-year-olds, you won’t get a date. Simple. Price your property correctly so that it competes well with the competition.
  • Quality of Photos/Descriptions – Make sure your photos are professional quality. No lame selfies taken in front of a mirror. Remember, your “dates” are making a split-second decision. Your photos online are your first impression. If you can’t take the time to properly represent yourself in a way that does you justice, you won’t be attractive to matches. Make sure your marketing descriptions are accurate and not too fluffy. Be honest but positive. No typos!
  • Choose an agent who is more expert than you are – Just as I had to ask my friend for help with online dating, your agent is there to guide you in an area that, for most sellers, is unfamiliar. We do real estate every day. You don’t. Work with an agent who is a full-time professional, who gives you honest advice (like “that shirt looks awful on you” and “don’t wear that in your profile photo”), who is experienced with all of the latest technology and advertising platforms and who can give you the most exposure to potential matches. Think of your realtor as your dating coach. He or she can help you find “the one” quickly and painlessly.

We’d love to hear more about your NJ real estate journey- and your dating adventures, too. We can advise you expertly on real estate. Dating – not so much.

The Allison Ziefert Real Estate Group is a top-producing real estate team based at Compass in Short Hills, New Jersey. We are local market experts, specializing in real estate and homes in Maplewood, South Orange, Millburn/Short Hills, Montclair/Glen Ridge, West Orange, Morristown, and the surrounding New Jersey towns. We’ve also got you covered coast to coast with the best connections to top agents around the country in any market you are exploring. We are driven by earning great testimonials and referral business from happy clients.

Recent Blog Posts

Real Estate

Northern New Jersey Housing Market 2026: Why Inventory Is Still So Low

A local perspective on what buyers and homeowners in Maplewood, Montclair, South Orange, and nearby towns should know right now

Blog

Do You Really Need a “Local” Real Estate Agent? What Northern NJ Buyers Should Know

A practical look at how buyers are actually searching across Maplewood, Montclair, Summit, and nearby towns today

Architectural Charm And Home Styles In Maplewood

If you love tree-lined streets, handcrafted details, and homes with real personality, Maplewood will feel like a dream.

Blog

Recognized Again: Platinum Level at the New Jersey Realtors® Circle of Excellence

Serving Maplewood, South Orange, Montclair, and Northern New Jersey with consistency, experience, and heart.

Living in Millburn, NJ: Lifestyle, Schools, & Costs

Discover what it’s like to live in Millburn, NJ - top-rated schools, community vibe, housing costs, commuting, and everyday lifestyle insights for families and profess… Read more

Blog

How Does Your Neighbor’s Sale Affect Your Home Value in Northern New Jersey?

If a home just sold in Maplewood, South Orange, Montclair, or a nearby town, here’s what that sale actually means — and what it doesn’t.

Millburn NJ Home Styles From Capes To Colonials

From cozy Capes to stately Colonials, Millburn and Short Hills offer a classic mix of homes that often look similar at first glance.

Blog

Is Boxcar a Smarter Commuting Option During NJ Transit Disruptions in Northern New Jersey?

A practical look at how temporary rail disruptions, alternative commuting options, and lifestyle priorities intersect for Northern New Jersey buyers and homeowners.

Living Near Paper Mill Playhouse In Millburn NJ

Living near the Paper Mill Playhouse puts you at the cultural center of Millburn’s compact downtown. The neighborhood blends tree‑lined residential streets and older s… Read more

Work With Us

We are passionate about researching market stats, negotiating contracts, and helping our clients find and sell homes. The majority of our business comes from past clients and referrals from people who know our work.

Follow Us